Not yet registered for the newsletter service?

Registration

Login

Forgot password? Reset it!

×

AB 2000 studies

Alain Boublil Blog

 

A wealthy but poorly managed France

The Bank of France and INSEE have just published statistics on the wealth of households, businesses, and public administrations for 2025. The contrast between these figures is striking and the alarmist and sometimes catastrophic rhetoric announcing a financial crisis and even the country's bankruptcy. This is what has caught investors' attention who, despite everything, continue to subscribe to French public debt issuances but under much less favorable conditions than in the past.

The 10-year government bond rate is approaching 5%, which is 1.5% more than what Germany pays for the same maturity. Before the dissolution of the National Assembly in 2024, the gap was only 0.8%. The resulting political instability and successive governments' inability to reduce public deficits have caused concern in financial markets, which has resulted in this rise in interest rates and a heavier debt burden.

This situation was worsened by the accompanying speech. It is a well-known method to get unpopular measures accepted. In the autumn, worrying estimates are published for the current year and pessimistic forecasts for the following year if nothing is done to remedy them. The following spring, a much better estimate of the past year is given but it goes completely unnoticed. This year, the results will not be good and will require substantial efforts to restore the accounts, but we are far from the catastrophic situation mentioned, and the publication of data relating to the assets of economic agents clearly shows this.

In 2025, household wealth reached 15,654 billion euros, after deducting their debts. It is composed two-thirds of real estate; their financial assets reached about 6,000 billion. In 2020, the corresponding figures were 13,440 billion and 5,400 billion, respectively. The stagnation in real estate values was more than offset by increases in other assets and a record financial savings rate.

Corporate equity increased sharply, rising from 11,686 billion to 15,154 billion. Unfortunately, this did not translate into a significant decrease in unemployment or a recovery in foreign trade. The wealth created was mainly allocated to shareholders and financed acquisitions abroad. Since the beginning of the year, these have reached more than 60 billion euros for CAC 40 companies.

The financial situation of public administrations has deteriorated much less than what emerges from speeches about the runaway public debt. The value of their real estate assets rose in five years from 2,367 to 2,945 billion, and that of their financial assets, mainly consisting of stakes in companies, from 1,579 to 1,778 billion. These assets are not sufficiently liquid to constitute collateral against a financial crisis, but a time-out-of-the-box program of real estate sales could help reduce the debt of the State and the organizations that hold them.

The French are generally wealthy, even if this wealth is unevenly distributed, which is a source of social tensions. The state, although heavily indebted, is therefore not on the edge of the abyss. It is, in fact, much less so than its American, Japanese, or British counterparts. But the criterion chosen (the ratio to GDP) gives a misleading impression. It would be much more justified to compare the evolution of its debt with the evolution of its financial assets. Between 2020 and 2025, despite a sharp increase in debt, the negative balance changed little, rising from 2,178 to 2,134 billion. The increasing valuation of real estate assets during this period practically offset the accumulation of deficits. The ratio between public debt and assets held by administrations therefore stabilized.

These figures help to better understand France's financial situation but do not exempt us from making savings that must be both significant and progressive. The waste of public money or its diversion to "administrative satellites," as well as the multiplication of political bodies at the local level, are all expenses that do not fuel growth and are carried out at the expense of the significant efforts the State must make to meet current challenges such as protection against global warming, the need for defense adapted to the international situation, or the possibility of offering young people training to find employment.

Public institutions do not set a good example. The budget of the National Assembly and the Senate, which also has a reserve of one billion placed in financial assets, exceeds one billion euros for 925 elected officials. The Court of Auditors has a budget of 200 million while most of its mission is now carried out by the regional chambers and devotes its time to drafting reports on public action, a mission assigned to the Economic, Social and Environmental Council.

The State is relieving itself of its operational functions in favor of "operators" whose numbers keep growing. But this does not mean that central administrations are offloading their missions. On the contrary, they recruit to control the actions of these operators. The amount of credits and taxes allocated in 2027 should approach 100 billion euros. The issue of pensions provides another example both of the country's wealth and its inability to manage. There is constant talk about upcoming deficits that must be filled with unpopular measures that only provoke protest and make it harder to adopt justified reforms and essential savings to reduce deficits.

Contributions go to the general scheme up to a certain ceiling. The rest goes to supplementary schemes. The general scheme deficit is included in public accounts but not the surpluses of supplementary schemes. According to a June 2026 report by the Pension Advisory Council, their reserves formed by accumulating their surpluses reached 208 billion. As for the Banque de France's special scheme, its reserves were 13.4 billion.

These reserves theoretically offer a guarantee for contributors, but it is illusory because they consist of illiquid real estate and financial assets which, in case of crisis, would largely disappear. By raising the contribution ceiling, the State can thus sustainably restore the balance of the general system. This will contribute to calming the social climate. Efforts to gradually reduce public spending will be better received, and the increase in its debt. Will be hindered Social peace has always been a necessary condition for successful reforms.

Lifestyle, administrative and territorial mille-feuille, and pensions—these are three areas of action to sustainably restore France's public accounts and restore its image with the markets. The resulting reduction in debt financing costs will initiate a virtuous circle of deficit reduction and place the country on a new growth trajectory, itself a factor of job creation and investment, and thus new revenues.

Instead of launching radical proposals that pit part of the population against another or lead to France's isolation in Europe and the world, it is urgent to become aware of the country's wealth to make it an asset to restore trust and not a divisive factor favorable to extremists.